The 2012 election provided two powerful reminders about the electoral implications of overly-concentrated Democratic voters. First, the Republicans held their U.S. House majority, won in 2010, despite the fact that the Democratic candidates in the 435 House districts received more votes than their Republican opponents. Second, these House results were...
Author: Thomas F. Schaller
The End of Amendments?
Why state legislative polarization makes constitutional amendments increasingly unlikely
This year marks the centennial anniversary of the first class of popularly-elected U.S. Senators, as mandated by adoption of the 17th Amendment. A hundred years later, several current or former Republican members of Congress, including Todd Akin (MO), Paul Broun (GA), Pete Hoekstra (MI) and Jeff Flake (AZ), have indicated...
HOW SHOULD WE VOTE?
Considering alternate ways to cast a ballot
In an earlier thought experiment for this site, I examined the history of multiple-member and statewide at-large districts in congressional elections, and wondered whether a movement away from the near-universal use of single-member districts (SMDs) in American legislative elections might be advisable and politically feasible. Electoral systems that feature SMDs...
Multi-Member Districts: Just a Thing of the Past?
Given that at least a third of Americans identify strongly with neither major party, it seems anomalous that the two major parties boast all but two of the 535 members of Congress, 49 of 50 state governors, 99% of the nearly 7,400 state legislators nationwide and every American president for...
Democrats Dread 2014 Drop-Off
At first blush, Saxby Chambliss and the Michigan right-to-work episode seem completely unrelated. Most Republicans approve of both, of course, but there is a deeper connection. The Georgia senator and Michigan’s effort to restrict organized labor’s power are both byproducts of a phenomenon that, despite the electoral problems currently facing...
WILL OBAMA’S FOREIGN POLICY WINS LEAD TO A WIN NEXT YEAR?
Presidents do not have a lot of leisure reading time, so it’s unlikely that Barack Obama has had time to flip through the pages of Harper’s November issue. And that’s probably good news for the president, because here are the first two entries of the famed “Harper’s Index” this month:...
ONE YEAR FROM CONVENTION, WHAT DOES OBAMA SAY?
With Barack Obama’s 2012 renomination speech in Charlotte now about a year away, here’s a very simple political question with a potentially complex answer: In his 2012 bid to win reelection, what messages and themes will the president employ? However good the field of potential Republican challengers may or may...
From the House to the White House? Not so fast
Michele Bachmann is surging. Newt Gingrich is struggling. And, as usual, Ron Paul is stirring the pot. The 2012 Republican presidential primary field is crowded -- specifically with current or former members of the U.S. House of Representatives. Indeed, Bachmann and Paul may very well be among the top performers...
Racial voting surge: Obama’s re-election and the Democrats’ 2006 Senate class
After two strong congressional cycles in 2006 and 2008, the Democrats were "shellacked" by Republicans in 2010. As the 2012 cycle approaches, uncertainty prevails for both parties: Each is trying to hold or expand its majority in one chamber while attempting to weaken and maybe topple the opposition in the...
The Latino Threshold
Where the GOP needs Latino votes and why
In the days immediately following the 2010 midterms several indisputable trends for the cycle were apparent. Voters were most concerned about the state of the economy, particularly unemployment, as well as the federal budget deficit. The Tea Party movement was the key, ground-level political force. And although the exact sums...
The Democrats’ Fab Four, Revisited
Sandwiched between the Democrats’ disappointing 2002 election cycle and their 2010 “shellacking,” the party made significant gains during the three, mid-decade intervening elections of 2004, 2006 and 2008. And nowhere were the party’s gains more impressive than in four states: Colorado, New Hampshire, Ohio and Virginia. This quartet of states...
Republicans’ Regional Recipe
Where the GOP must win to capture the House
With a dozen weeks to go before the 2010 midterm elections, speculation is rising about the possibility of the Republicans retaking the House. On Sunday, that speculation rose to a fevered pitch when White House press secretary Robert Gibbs conceded during a Meet The Press appearance that there are enough...