Romney’s Opponents Look for the Spirit of ‘76


While Mitt Romney may very well be on his way to winning the GOP nomination, he is not completely out of the woods yet. With so many primaries and caucuses left to be decided, it is perfectly possible that other candidates will win some of the remaining states as long as they stay in the race. We only have to look at the party nomination struggles in 1976 to see how frontrunners who started fast ended up facing long, hard slogs to the nomination.

In 1976 President Gerald Ford faced off in a head-to-head matchup against conservative standard-bearer Ronald Reagan in the Republican field. The incumbent galloped out to a large early lead by winning Iowa, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Vermont, Florida and Illinois. However, beginning in North Carolina on March 23, Ronald Reagan began winning many states in the South and Midwest. In the end, neither candidate had a clear majority of delegates when they arrived at the Republican convention in Kansas City. Only deference to the sitting (if unelected) president by enough uncommitted delegates allowed Gerald Ford to defeat Reagan for the nomination by a narrow margin.

Meanwhile, on the Democratic side, Jimmy Carter seemed to be gaining the upper hand by early May, having outlasted opponents such as Sen. Henry “Scoop” Jackson of Washington and the Georgian’s chief southern rival, Alabama Gov. George Wallace. However, Carter’s victories in the majority of state primaries and in many state caucuses encouraged the development of an “Anybody But Carter” (ABC) movement among liberal Democrats who worried that Carter was too conservative for the party. The main ABC antagonists proved to be Idaho Sen. Frank Church and Gov. Jerry Brown of California, who each managed to win several states down the stretch. Nevertheless, their candidacies, coupled with that of liberal Rep. Morris Udall of Arizona, were self-defeating, and they split the ABC vote, helping Carter wrap up the Democratic nomination by the early June conclusion of the primary season.

Much like Carter, Mitt Romney has been aided by a fragmented anti-Romney vote in 2012. That is no guarantee that Romney will win all the upcoming contests; at some point, just as we saw 36 years ago, the early frontrunner can lose steam and be defeated in major primaries and caucuses down the road. Maybe the GOP nomination battle this year will effectively end early in South Carolina and Florida, but if it does not, Mitt Romney could take heart from the fact that the candidates who got off to a strong start in 1976, Ford and Carter, ultimately won their nominations. In the challenging marathon of a presidential race, other entrants can catch up to the frontrunner on the track from time to time, but the contender who proved his mettle early on can prove awfully hard to beat at the tape.