Skip links

Sabato’s Crystal Ball

What to Watch for in the Wisconsin Supreme Court race

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — In one of the biggest elections of the calendar year, a Democratic-aligned justice appears favored in next week’s Wisconsin state Supreme Court election. But that was also true in 2019, when a Republican-aligned justice pulled an upset. — Democrats often underperform in such races in Milwaukee, so that is a key place to watch. — Judicial voting patterns largely reflect voting in partisan races, but there are some key differences. Next week’s Wisconsin Supreme Court race Next week, Badger State voters will head to the polls to weigh in on what has been billed as the most important judicial election of the year. If Democratic-aligned Judge Janet Protasiewicz prevails, liberals will assume a 4-3 majority on the state’s highest court. If voters send Daniel Kelly, a former justice who is effectively the GOP nominee in the contest, back to the body, conservatives will retain control. From what we can tell, Protasiewicz is a favorite, although given the marginal nature of Wisconsin, we wouldn’t rule out a Kelly win. One indicator has been fundraising. Given the stakes, the race has been expensive: the two sides have combined to spend at least $26 million. Protasiewicz has

J. Miles Coleman

The Transformation of the American Electorate

Tags
  KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — The American electorate has changed dramatically over the past 40 years, and a pair of factors — race and education — have driven the changes. — The electorate has become more diverse and more highly educated. Democrats rely heavily on nonwhite voters and have improved with white college-educated voters, while Republicans have cut deeply into Democratic support with non-college whites. — Racial and cultural issues, rather than economic ones, have fueled Republican gains with the non-college white electorate. How the electorate has changed The American electorate has changed dramatically over the past 4 decades. This transformation has involved changes in both the demographic composition of the electorate and the party loyalties of major demographic groups. In this essay, I describe long-term trends in the demographic composition of the electorate and in the party loyalties of key demographic groups, focusing on two crucial demographic variables: race and education. I then examine the forces driving the striking shift in the party loyalties of the group that still makes up the largest share of the American electorate — white voters without a college degree, a group often referred to as the white working class. Demographic change

Alan I. Abramowitz

A First Look at 2024 State Supreme Court Contests

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — The fate of Wisconsin’s state supreme court will be decided next month. — About two-thirds of the states will have supreme court elections next year. — Key states with supreme court elections to watch in 2024 include Kentucky, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina, and Ohio. The 2024 high court races A high-stakes state supreme court election that will determine the ideological control of the Wisconsin Supreme Court is set to take place on April 4. The contest between liberal judge Janet Protasiewicz and conservative candidate Daniel Kelly, who was involved in the state GOP’s “fake elector” scheme after the 2020 presidential election, is on track to become the most expensive judicial race in history. Another key swing state, Pennsylvania, also has a state supreme court race this year to fill a currently-vacant seat previously held by late Chief Justice Max Baer, a Democrat. Democrats still have a 4-2 edge on the court, so they would retain the majority even if Republicans win the seat later this year. With growing attention being given to the role of state courts in determining political representation and other key issues, we look ahead to state supreme court elections in

Carah Ong Whaley

The Republican Presidential Primary: Still Early, but Maybe Getting Late

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — The calendar year before the presidential primary voting begins is often defined by winnowing, as contenders emerge and then fade. — But Donald Trump and Ron DeSantis are taking up so much oxygen that we may already have the top contenders, with everyone else who runs essentially an afterthought. — DeSantis is polling well for a non-candidate, but we need to see how he actually performs before assuming that his support is solid. — If another candidate supplants DeSantis (or Trump), or at least vaults into their stratosphere, don’t necessarily assume it will be someone who is currently well-known now or has a lot of formal political experience. Assessing the GOP presidential primary It feels late — and also early — in the race for the Republican presidential nomination. It may be late because despite the fact that we are still nearly a year away from the actual voting, the top 2 contenders seem to be so clear. The winnowing process that so often defines the year in advance of the primary voting may have effectively already happened – it’s just that the winnowed candidates, some of whom aren’t even candidates yet, don’t know

Kyle Kondik and J. Miles Coleman

Republicans Retain Edge in Electoral College Tie

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — If no candidate receives a majority of Electoral College votes, the U.S. House of Representatives elected in the 2024 election would decide the presidency. — Republicans are very likely to continue to control enough House delegations to select the GOP nominee as the winner, meaning that 269 is effectively the winning Electoral College number for Republicans, while it’s 270 for Democrats. — Republicans currently control 26 of the 50 House delegations, the bare majority to win in the House if the Electoral College does not produce a majority winner. Breaking an Electoral College tie Next year, 2024, coincides with a pair of bicentennial anniversaries in American presidential election history. The presidential election of 1824 was the first one in which there is a tabulation of the actual popular vote for president, albeit not from every state. A majority of states in the Union at the time had adopted a popular vote for presidential electors; previously, presidential electors had generally been chosen by state legislatures. Thus, one can describe 2024 as representing the 200th anniversary of a popular vote for president, even if the totals represented only 18 of the 24 states voting at the

Kyle Kondik

Liz Cheney to Serve as Professor of Practice with UVA Center for Politics

Tags
The Center for Politics at the University of Virginia announced Wednesday that former Rep. Liz Cheney (R-WY) has accepted an appointment to serve as a Professor of Practice with the Center for Politics. The inaugural appointment is effective immediately and will run through the conclusion of the 2023 fall semester with an option to renew for one or more additional years. “I am delighted to be joining the UVA Center for Politics as a Professor of Practice. Preserving our constitutional republic is the most important work of our time, and our nation’s young people will play a crucial role in this effort. I look forward to working with students and colleagues at the Center to advance the important work they and others at the University of Virginia are doing to improve the health of democracy here and around the world,” said Cheney. “There are many threats facing our system of government and I hope my work with the Center for Politics and the broader community at the University of Virginia will contribute to finding lasting solutions that not only preserve but strengthen our democracy.” “The Board of Visitors, which endorsed a Statement on Free Expression and Free Inquiry in 2021,

UVA Center for Politics

Notes on the State of Politics: March 1, 2023

Tags
Dear Readers: This is the latest edition of Notes on the State of Politics, which features short updates on elections and politics. — The Editors How likely is an Electoral College tie? The 2020 election came fairly close to ending in an Electoral College tie. While Joe Biden won the national popular vote by about 4.5 points, his margins in several key states were much narrower. Specifically, Biden’s 3 closest wins were by 11,779 votes (or .24 percentage points) in Georgia, 10,457 in Arizona (.31 points), and 20,682 (.63 points) in Wisconsin. Had these states voted for Donald Trump and everything else had been the same, the Electoral College would have produced a 269-269 tie, leaving both candidates short of the magic number of 270 electoral votes. If this ever happens, the U.S. House of Representatives would have to decide the election — we’ll have more about how this would work in tomorrow’s Crystal Ball. But before we do that, we wanted to look at whether there are plausible paths to 269-269 in 2024. Changes to the electoral vote allocations as a result of the 2020 census have altered the overall math slightly. Using the new allocation based on the 2020

Kyle Kondik and J. Miles Coleman

Initial House Ratings: Battle for Majority Starts as a Toss-up

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — The overall battle for House control in 2024 starts as a Toss-up. — Relatively similar numbers of Democratic and Republican seats start in the most competitive Toss-up and Leans categories, although Republicans start with a few more targets in large part because of the likelihood that they will benefit from redistricting in North Carolina and Ohio. — Big blue states California and New York, where Republicans have made key gains over the past couple of cycles, loom large as Democrats plot a path back to the House majority. The House at the starting gate After consecutive election cycles in which the favored side won the House, but by significantly smaller margins than many (including us) expected, we want to be clear from the start how we’re viewing the House this cycle: The race for the majority begins as a Toss-up. While midterms, and not presidential years, much more frequently serve as the engine of change in the House — 10 of the last 12 shifts in power came in midterm cycles — it is also rare for a midterm to produce such a small majority for the winning side as last year’s did. The

Kyle Kondik

Notes on the State of Politics: February 22, 2023

Tags
Dear Readers: Tonight’s event with Bill Kristol and David Ramadan has been postponed, although we are hoping to reschedule it for some time in the spring. — The Editors KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — In Virginia, Democrats have held the Richmond-area 4th District with state Sen. Jennifer McClellan. Her nearly 50-point win represented a notable overperformance. — The most important judicial race of this year will be in the closely-divided state of Wisconsin, where control of the state Supreme Court is on the line. — In last night’s judicial primary, Democratic-aligned candidates took 54% of the two-way vote in Wisconsin. This could bode well for liberal judge Janet Protasiewicz, who will face conservative Daniel Kelly in April, although there have been surprises in past state Supreme Court elections. Last night’s Virginia and Wisconsin results Last night, in what was probably the most widely followed election night so far this year, Democrats overperformed in several special elections across the country. With the 2022 general election out of the way, last night almost seemed like a return to form: After the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision in summer 2022, Democrats routinely overperformed President Joe Biden’s margins in a string of congressional elections

J. Miles Coleman

Both White and Nonwhite Democrats are Moving Left

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — One of the big stories of American politics over the past half-century has been a growing ideological divide between Democrats and Republicans. — This has also led to more ideological cohesion within parties, including a dramatic increase among Democrats between 2012 and 2020. Democrats are now as ideologically cohesive as Republicans, which is a big change from a decade ago, when Republicans were significantly more cohesive than Democrats. — While white Democrats have moved more to the left than nonwhite Democrats have on some issues, both groups have become more liberal since 2012. Ideological congruence in the American electorate Growing partisan-ideological congruence has been one of the most important trends affecting American politics over the past several decades. The ideological divide between Democrats and Republicans has increased dramatically since the 1970s as Republicans have grown increasingly conservative and Democrats have grown increasingly liberal. This increase in partisan-ideological congruence has affected rank-and-file voters as well as party elites and activists. In this article, I use data from American National Election Studies surveys to examine trends in partisan-ideological congruence among Democratic and Republican voters since 2012. To measure partisan-ideological congruence, I examine trends in ideological identification and

Alan I. Abramowitz

The Senate Primaries to Watch So Far

Tags
  Dear Readers: Join us next Wednesday, Feb. 22 for “A Conversation with Former/Future Republicans Bill Kristol and David Ramadan.” Kristol, a longtime political commentator, and Ramadan, a Center for Politics scholar and former member of the Virginia House of Delegates, will discuss the past and future of the Republican Party and their concerns about the state of our democracy. Their conversation will be held from 6:30 p.m. to 8 p.m. eastern at the Colonnade Club Solarium on the Grounds of the University of Virginia. It is free and open to the public with advanced registration through Eventbrite, and it will also be streamed at https://livestream.com/tavco/defendingdemocracytogether. — The Editors KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — It has been over a decade since an incumbent senator was successfully primaried in a regularly-scheduled election; though a few senators may be vulnerable, 2024 may continue that streak. — Sen. Dianne Feinstein’s (D-CA) decision to retire removed one vulnerable senator from the primary conversation; Sen. Kyrsten Sinema’s (I-AZ) decision to leave the Democratic Party removed another. Among the other incumbents who are still deciding whether to run for reelection, Sen. Mitt Romney (R-UT) stands out as someone who could hypothetically be vulnerable in a primary.

Kyle Kondik and J. Miles Coleman

The State of Biden’s Next Campaign

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — President Biden’s successful State of the Union address suggested he’s full speed ahead on running for a second term. — Despite polls showing that even many Democrats would prefer Biden not to run again, he has no real opposition within his own party — and the State of the Union is unlikely to help generate any. — Biden’s best friend is weakness within the Republican Party, which was on display once again on Tuesday night. Biden’s State of the Union There are competing realities at the heart of the president’s annual State of the Union address. It is both typically unmemorable, yet also is probably the biggest scheduled event on the political calendar. This is particularly true in odd-numbered years, in which there are few elections of national import. Content-wise, State of the Union addresses are typically formulaic, a laundry list of presidential accomplishments and asks. While many inaugural addresses have stood the test of time, State of the Union addresses typically have not. The Library of America’s American Speeches: Political Oratory from Abraham Lincoln to Bill Clinton includes only a single State of the Union address in its collection: Franklin Roosevelt’s Jan. 6, 1941 address to Congress in

Kyle Kondik and J. Miles Coleman

The Shocking Decline of Senate Ticket-Splitting

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — Senate races are increasingly converging with presidential partisanship, to the point where the huge overperformances that were so common a decade or two ago have become much less common. — Since 2000, the number of senators who have run more than 10 points ahead of their party’s presidential nominee has decreased sharply. — This trend helps explain why we currently rate Democratic-held West Virginia as Leans Republican and started off Montana and Ohio as Toss-ups. Senate race trends since 2000 Last week, when we put out our first look at the 2024 Senate map, we issued a rare rating: We started an incumbent off as an underdog. Specifically, we put the West Virginia contest in the Leans Republican category. Though Sen. Joe Manchin has not officially announced his plans, the reality is that any Democrat, even as one as successful as Manchin, faces a daunting challenge in West Virginia. Some of Manchin’s worries are state-specific. One of the (several) unexpected success stories for national Democrats last year was their showing in state legislative races: They gained governmental trifectas in several states and held their own in the overall state legislative seat count across the

J. Miles Coleman

Initial Senate Ratings: Democrats Have a Lot of Defending to Do

Tags
Dear Readers: Please join us this week for a pair of special Center for Politics forums, both of which are free and open to the public and will also be livestreamed. Today (Tuesday, Jan. 24) at 4 p.m., we will host the ambassador of Chile, Juan Gabriel Valdés, at the UVA Rotunda Dome Room. He will discuss the relationship between Chile and the U.S., Chile’s recent constitutional referendum, and other issues impacting Chile and the region. Tickets are available through Eventbrite, and it will be streamed at https://livestream.com/tavco/ambassadorofchile. On Friday, Jan. 27 at 2:30 p.m. at the UVA Small Special Collections Library Auditorium, Bob Woodward of the Washington Post and Robert Costa of CBS News will discuss their bestselling book on the transition from the Trump administration to the Biden administration, Peril, which is now out in paperback and will be available for sale at the event. Woodward and Costa will stay after the event to sign books. Tickets are available through Eventbrite, and it will be streamed at https://livestream.com/tavco/perilbookdiscussion. This morning, we are rolling out our first Senate ratings of the 2024 cycle. This is our only planned issue of the Crystal Ball this week, although we invite you to

Kyle Kondik

2024 Governors Races: A First Look

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — North Carolina’s open-seat race is clearly the marquee contest of 2024’s gubernatorial races. It starts as a Toss-up. — The other contests start with clear favorites despite several open seats. — If popular Republican incumbents run for another term, the GOP should be in great shape to hold New Hampshire and Vermont. But they would be great Democratic opportunities as open seats. — Mississippi moves to Likely Republican following the entry of a credible Democratic candidate after our initial 2023 rating release last week. Table 1: Crystal Ball gubernatorial rating change Governor Old Rating New Rating Tate Reeves (R-MS) Safe Republican Likely Republican Map 1: Crystal Ball 2023/2024 gubernatorial ratings The 2024 gubernatorial races Following up on our initial 2023 gubernatorial ratings post from last week, we’ll look a bit further down the road with a survey of 2024’s races. Our home state, Virginia, will be at the center of the action — sort of. This year, the key contest will be our neighbor to the west, Kentucky. In 2024, our southern neighbor, North Carolina, will likely be the most hotly contested gubernatorial contest. The 2022 cycle proved to be a banner year for

J. Miles Coleman

JFK Records Reveal Intense Level of Secrecy by CIA During Investigation of Assassination

Tags
Calling it “the tip of the iceberg,” Professor Larry J. Sabato and the Center for Politics at UVA released details today of new information discovered in records released by the National Archives last month from the collection of President John F. Kennedy Assassination Records. Among the findings was a previously unknown relationship between the CIA and then-President of Mexico to run a “telephone tap center.” The operation intercepted Lee Harvey Oswald’s call in Mexico City to the Soviet embassy a month before JFK’s assassination seeking a Cuban transit visa as a means of returning to the Soviet Union. The source of the tap had not been revealed to the public prior to last month. According to the new record, the Mexican President’s cooperation with the CIA at the time was also “not known to Mexican security and law enforcement officials.” Other records show the clandestine phone tap operation was so deeply classified that the CIA resorted to extraordinary measures to conceal it even from the Justice Department as the department prepared a major report on the Kennedy assassination. One newly released document from November 27, 1963, shows the CIA requesting permission from President Adolfo Lopez Mateos and Mexico’s then Secretary

UVA Center for Politics

The 2023 Governor Races

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — While it’s easy to begin looking towards the 2024 election cycle, 3 states will have gubernatorial contests this year. — In Kentucky, Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear remains personally popular, but he will be running in a red state with a large GOP bench. — Louisiana and Mississippi should be easier contests for Republicans. Term-limited Gov. John Bel Edwards (D-LA) will be hard for Democrats to replace, while Mississippi, where Democrats have not won a gubernatorial contest this century, will also be an uphill fight for them. — The initial ratings for these 3 races are Leans Democratic for Kentucky, Safe Republican for Mississippi, and Likely Republican for Louisiana. Rating the 2023 gubernatorial races With the 2022 midterms finally in the books, it’s time to start looking to the 2024 presidential race. Just kidding. While we will have no shortage of 2024 content on tap, 2023 will see many of its own elections. In our own backyard, this November’s legislative races in Virginia, where each party narrowly controls a chamber of the legislature, will have implications for the commonwealth. Democrats may be feeling more confident after Tuesday night, as they flipped a marginal state Senate seat in the

J. Miles Coleman

Michigan’s Open Senate Seat: Democrats’ Swing State Retirement Drought Ends

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — Sen. Debbie Stabenow’s (D-MI) decision to retire at the end of her term gives Democrats a liability they have not had in the last few Senate cycles: An open seat to defend in a key presidential battleground. — They arguably have a second in Arizona, too, given Sen. Kyrsten Sinema’s decision to become an independent and the likelihood of Democrats nominating a credible alternative to Sinema. — Retirements are arguably easier to mitigate than they used to be because of the growing correlation between presidential and down-ballot results. But retirements can have ripple effects on the overall Senate battlefield. — Democrats still start with an edge to hold Stabenow’s seat, and the burden of proof is on Republicans to produce a strong nominee after the party had an awful election in Michigan last year. Playing defense in open seats Last week’s retirement announcement by Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) gives Democrats a liability they really have not had in the last 3 Senate election cycles: An open seat in a competitive state. In 2018, 2020, and 2022 — a full rotation of all 3 Senate classes, meaning every single seat was contested over that timeframe

Kyle Kondik

The Political Profile of McCarthy’s Detractors

Tags
KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — This article is being published following the adjournment of the House on the afternoon of Wednesday, Jan. 4 after the body failed to elect a speaker on 6 roll call votes held Tuesday and Wednesday. The House was scheduled to return at 8 p.m. eastern on Wednesday. — The 21 Republicans who did not vote for Kevin McCarthy on every roll call generally, but not exclusively, come from uncompetitive districts. They almost all appear to have at least some connection to the House Freedom Caucus, the group of hardline conservatives. — Some recent choices by GOP electorates helped strengthen what would become this anti-McCarthy coalition. — The longer this goes on, the more need there may be for a creative solution, like we saw in Pennsylvania’s state House speaker election on Tuesday. Profiling the McCarthy opposition The U.S. House of Representatives did something on Tuesday that it had not done in a century — go to a second ballot for speaker. Then it went to a third, without resolution. Votes 4, 5, and 6 happened on Wednesday, with almost exactly the same results as those held on Tuesday. No clear resolution is in sight

Kyle Kondik

McCarthy, Santos, and a Tenuous GOP Majority

Tags
Dear Readers: The event scheduled for Friday evening featuring law enforcement officers who defended the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021 has been postponed. Keep your eye on this space for more information about this event and other upcoming Center for Politics programs this winter and spring. — The Editors KEY POINTS FROM THIS ARTICLE — The GOP’s House majority begins today with what could be a historic vote — or votes — for Speaker of the House. — Kevin McCarthy and George Santos, the focus of so much recent House coverage, may end up being short-termers as, respectively, Speaker of the House and a member of the House. But it would be hard for either to break records for brevity of service. — Voters in 2022 did what midterm voters often do — put a check on the White House. — But the 2022 verdict was so mixed that the House majority is once again up for grabs in 2024. The House at the dawn of a new GOP majority The pair of biggest developments in the U.S. House over the holiday season prompted us to look at the history books. Our queries were: What is the shortest-ever tenure for

Kyle Kondik